Peer feedback is most useful when learners have time to evaluate it, not just collect it. Ask them to identify what each comment refers to, check it against the brief and criteria, and decide whether to act, adapt the suggestion or ask the tutor for clarification.
The exercise below uses a fictional draft before learners review each other’s work. Peer comments are formative advice: they do not replace the assessor’s judgement or guarantee a particular result.
Prepare the activity
First, check that the assessment and awarding organisation’s rules permit this kind of peer review. Explain what learners may share and discuss, whether any acknowledgement is required, and where collaboration must stop. If review of a live assignment is not permitted, use a separate practice task instead.
Give learners the relevant brief and criteria, a short draft and a focused feedback prompt. Plan the session early enough for them to revise and ask questions before submission. UCL Arena’s guidance on helping students understand assessment recommends criterion-linked prompts, examples of useful feedback and tutor follow-up. ([ucl.ac.uk](https://www.ucl.ac.uk/teaching-learning/publications/2019/aug/helping-students-understand-assessment?utm_source=openai))
For a first attempt, allow around 35 minutes: five to introduce the criterion, eight to discuss the fictional example, eight for peer review, ten for decisions and revision, and four for questions. Adapt the timings to the task and learners’ needs.
Model a decision using a fictional draft
In this practice task, learners recommend how a fictional community service could reduce missed appointments. The brief asks them to use the supplied figures to justify a recommendation and acknowledge one practical limitation.
Criterion: Use relevant evidence to support a recommendation and recognise a limitation in the evidence.
Draft:
I recommend continuing appointment reminders. Missed appointments fell from 24 out of 60 to 9 out of 60 after reminders were introduced. We should therefore continue reminders.
Ask the group: “Where does the draft use evidence, and what does it not yet explain?” The figures are relevant, but the paragraph does not acknowledge that other changes might also have contributed to the fall. The figures alone do not establish that reminders caused it.
Consider conflicting advice
Imagine that two peers respond:
- Peer A: “Add every monthly figure and another chart so the recommendation has more evidence.”
- Peer B: “Delete the numbers. Your recommendation is clear without them.”
Neither comment needs to be followed in full. Peer A notices the need for evidence, but the brief does not require every figure or a chart. Peer B values clarity, but removing the numbers would make the recommendation less well supported.
The learner could retain the two relevant figures and add a limitation:
I recommend continuing reminders. Missed appointments fell from 24 out of 60 to 9 out of 60 after reminders were introduced. Reminders may have contributed, but other changes could also explain the fall.
This is one possible response to the fictional brief, not a model answer for every assessment. It shows how a learner can consider both comments while using the criterion to make an independent decision.
Give peers a focused prompt
Once learners have practised on the fictional paragraph, pair them to review an allowed excerpt of their own work. Ask reviewers to comment on the work rather than the person, and to point to a specific passage.
For the example criterion, use this prompt:
Where does the writer use evidence to support the recommendation? Identify one relevant passage. What, if anything, would help a reader understand a limitation? Refer to the criterion rather than rewriting the answer for them.
Invite one observation about what is working and one question or suggestion for development. For a different assessment, replace the prompt with one tied to its published criteria. UCL’s writing guidance offers further peer-feedback questions and reminds students to evaluate advice before making changes. ([ucl.ac.uk](https://www.ucl.ac.uk/ioe/departments-and-centres/academic-writing-centre/resources-academic-reading-and-writing/reviewing-editing-and-responding-feedback?utm_source=openai))
Give learners time to decide and revise
After receiving comments, ask each learner to make a brief decision note. It can be written, discussed or completed in another accessible format:
- Locate: Which passage does the comment refer to?
- Check: Which part of the brief or criterion is relevant? Does the suggestion fit the task and its rules?
- Decide: Will I act on it, adapt it, leave the work as it is, or ask the tutor?
- Explain: What is my reason, and what will I change if appropriate?
For the fictional example, a decision note might read: “Keep the figures because the criterion asks for evidence. Do not add a chart because the brief does not ask for one. Add a sentence acknowledging another possible explanation.” The learner can then make the revision and reread the whole paragraph for clarity.
Build this response time into the session rather than leaving revision as an unspecified extra. Durham University’s peer-review guidance also recommends making criteria clear and planning how students will use feedback. ([helpguides.webspace.durham.ac.uk](https://helpguides.webspace.durham.ac.uk/approaches/active-pedagogy/collaborative-learning/facilitating-peer-feedback-peer-review/?utm_source=openai))
Provide a route to the tutor
Tell learners how and when to raise uncertainty: for example, through a question at the end of the session or an agreed message before a stated deadline. They might ask, “Does this criterion require a chart, or is a concise explanation with figures sufficient?”
Respond by clarifying the brief and criteria within the permitted feedback rules, rather than promising a mark or writing the learner’s answer. If several learners have the same question, share the clarification with the group where appropriate. If the issue cannot be resolved immediately, ask the learner to note the uncertainty and continue with other permitted work until the tutor responds.
Offer an alternative if a learner cannot participate in a pair, has no draft ready or is uncomfortable sharing it. They might review another fictional excerpt and discuss their decisions with the tutor. Use an accessible format, and avoid sharing confidential workplace or personal information in drafts.
Keep peer review separate from marking
After submission, the assessor applies the published criteria to the work submitted. A peer’s recommendation, or a learner’s decision not to follow it, is not itself an assessment judgement.
Witful Studio is a separate marking workspace that brings submitted work, criteria and assessor feedback together. It does not need to host the peer-review exercise described here; the assessor remains responsible for the marking decision. ([edumark.ai](https://www.edumark.ai/marking-studio?utm_source=openai))
Sources & further reading
See how Witful connects learning, assessment and your team.
Explore Witful →



