By EduMark team

To test judgement in an open-book assessment, give learners a situation that cannot be answered by copying a definition. Ask them to select relevant information, make a decision and explain why it fits the circumstances. Then mark the quality of their reasoning, not simply the choice they make.

Start with the intended learning outcome and check whether the proposed task actually tests it. Nottingham Trent University’s open-book guidance recommends scenario-based questions that require application rather than the reproduction of source material. Its guidance was written for online assessments in 2020, so use its design ideas alongside your current institutional and awarding-body rules. ([ntu.ac.uk](https://www.ntu.ac.uk/media/documents/adq/flexible-learning-documentation/online-open-book-assessments.pdf))

Turn a definition into a decision

Suppose the learning outcome is to choose a suitable staff training approach and justify that choice. A question such as ‘Define self-directed learning’ checks whether a learner can find or recall a definition. It tells you little about whether they can use the idea.

Instead, provide a short scenario with a real choice, relevant facts and enough uncertainty to make the reasoning visible. The following example is fictional and can be adapted to the level of the course.

Example task: choosing an induction approach

A small organisation must provide an induction activity for 12 new staff within two weeks. Its budget is £700.

Option A: A facilitated workshop costs £600. Sessions are available on both day and night shifts.

Option B: A self-directed activity costs £250. It takes 30 minutes per person and can be completed at any time. Eight staff, including four who work nights, use one shared device; only one person can use it at a time.

The course notes explain that facilitated activities allow immediate questions, while self-directed activities offer flexibility. The organisation has no evidence yet about which option staff would find more useful.

Recommend one option. Use the scenario and course notes to justify your decision, explain one trade-off compared with the other option, and identify one piece of information you would seek before delivery. Write approximately 200–250 words.

A learner might choose the workshop because questions can be answered immediately and sessions are available across shifts, while noting the higher cost. Another might choose the self-directed activity because it is less expensive and flexible, while recognising that the shared device needs scheduling. Both can be credible: neither the lower price nor the learner’s preferred option is sufficient on its own.

Write criteria that reward the thinking

For this example, use four criteria worth three marks each. Share them before the assessment and adapt them to your approved marking scheme.

  • Decision and feasibility: Makes a clear recommendation and explains how it could be delivered within the budget and two-week period.
  • Application: Connects a relevant idea from the course notes to at least two facts in the scenario.
  • Comparison: Explains a meaningful trade-off between the chosen option and the alternative.
  • Uncertainty and next step: Identifies a relevant information gap and explains how finding out would help delivery.

For each criterion, a simple starting point is: 3 marks for a clear, relevant and well-supported response; 2 for a relevant but partially developed response; 1 for a limited response; and 0 for no relevant evidence. Before use, agree with colleagues what those descriptions look like for each criterion. Do not award marks for an invented fact as though it appeared in the scenario.

Try marking a few fictional responses together. Check that a short, well-reasoned answer can receive credit and that a long summary of the notes does not automatically score highly. Accept different recommendations when the reasoning meets the criteria.

Make the open-book rules explicit

‘Open book’ does not by itself tell learners which resources or types of help are allowed. Put the rules beside the task, and check that they match the assessment regulations. For the example above, a brief might state:

  • Permitted: Your own course notes and the supplied course materials.
  • Not permitted: Internet searches, generative AI tools or discussion with another person during the assessment.
  • Attribution: Name the course note or other permitted source when you use an idea from it. Use quotation marks for copied wording. A full bibliography is not required for this example.
  • Independent work: Write your own response and follow the organisation’s academic integrity rules.

These are example conditions, not universal open-book rules. Your institution may permit different resources or require a particular referencing style. NTU’s guidance recommends making the expected level of referencing clear rather than leaving learners to guess. ([ntu.ac.uk](https://www.ntu.ac.uk/media/documents/adq/flexible-learning-documentation/online-open-book-assessments.pdf))

Check timing and accessibility before release

For this short example, you might propose a 30-minute working time, including reading, consulting notes and writing. Test that estimate with colleagues or a practice group: can they find relevant information and complete a considered answer without rushing? If there is a longer submission window, distinguish that window from the expected working time. Apply any approved individual arrangements in line with your organisation’s process.

The University of Bath’s inclusive assessment guidance recommends clear expectations, practice and attention to access. Before publishing, check the following: ([teachinghub.bath.ac.uk](https://teachinghub.bath.ac.uk/guide/inclusive-assessment-design/))

  • Are the scenario and instructions available in an accessible format, including for learners using assistive technology?
  • Can everyone access the permitted materials and a suitable place or alternative provision for the assessment?
  • Have learners practised a similar question and, where relevant, the submission process?
  • Are approved adjustments and any alternative formats arranged without changing the intended learning outcome?

A short practice task can reveal whether learners spend their time applying ideas or searching through an unmanageable collection of notes. Revise the instructions or resource list if the practice exposes a barrier.

Review the response against the criteria

When marking, look for the connection between the scenario, the relevant course idea and the learner’s explanation. Record why the response meets or falls short of each criterion, especially where a reasonable recommendation differs from your own.

EduMark Marking Studio is a workspace for reviewing submitted work alongside the question and criteria, and recording feedback. The assessor remains responsible for the judgement. ([edumark.ai](https://www.edumark.ai/marking-studio))

Sources & further reading

A little less admin. A lot more possibility.

See how EduMark connects learning, assessment and your team.

Explore EduMark →