By Witful team

Before offering an alternative assessment task, compare it with the original side by side. Check the skills and content covered, the reasoning required, the information provided, the assessment conditions and the marking guidance. Then ask a second reviewer to work through both tasks and challenge the differences.

The aim is not to make the scenarios identical. It is to judge whether each gives learners a comparable opportunity to demonstrate the required knowledge and skills. This review supports professional judgement; it does not prove that two assessments are equivalent.

First, check who is permitted to set or adapt the task. For an awarding organisation’s qualification, follow its current specification, assessment rules and approval process. For qualifications regulated by Ofqual in England, Condition G1.2 requires awarding organisations to take all reasonable steps to ensure consistent levels of demand across task options and alternative assessments. Other qualification-specific rules may also apply. ([gov.uk](https://www.gov.uk/guidance/ofqual-handbook/section-g-setting-and-delivering-the-assessment))

A fictional example: choosing a supplier

Imagine a training provider is permitted to write two versions of a task. In each version, learners must recommend a supplier for an order and justify their choice using cost, lead time and past on-time delivery. The maximum budget is £12,000. Both tasks use the same criteria: compare relevant information, justify a decision and identify a risk.

Learners have 40 minutes, may use the supplied information only, and must produce a short recommendation. Approved adjustments still apply.

Version A: a trade-off

  • Oak: £9,000; four-week lead time; 92% of previous orders delivered on time.
  • Pine: £11,000; two-week lead time; 98% of previous orders delivered on time.

Both suppliers are within budget. Oak costs less, while Pine is faster and has a stronger delivery record. Learners need to decide how to weigh those differences and explain the risk of their choice. The past delivery figures do not guarantee future performance.

Version B: the choice becomes obvious

  • Alder: £8,000; two-week lead time; 99% of previous orders delivered on time.
  • Birch: £10,000; four-week lead time; 94% of previous orders delivered on time.

Here, Alder is cheaper, faster and has the stronger delivery record. A learner can still describe the figures, but the task offers less opportunity to weigh competing advantages. Keeping the same criteria has not kept the reasoning demand the same.

Possible revision: change Alder to £8,000, four weeks and 92%; change Birch to £10,000, two weeks and 98%. The revised version now presents a cost-versus-delivery trade-off, like Version A. It still needs review: matching this pattern alone does not establish equivalent demand.

Use a side-by-side review

Put the full briefs, supplied materials, criteria and marking guidance next to one another. Record a finding and any action for each check.

CheckQuestions for the reviewers
CoverageDo both versions give learners a chance to demonstrate every required skill and area of content? Is any criterion harder to evidence in one version?
ComplexityHow many decisions and trade-offs are needed? Can one answer be selected by spotting a single dominant option, while the other requires a judgement?
Available informationAre the amount, relevance and clarity of information comparable? Does either version provide an unexplained advantage, such as a ready-made recommendation?
ConditionsCompare time, permitted resources, format and supervision. Can learners reasonably complete each task under the stated conditions, with approved adjustments where applicable?
Marking guidanceDo the same criteria and weighting apply? Does the guidance explain how to credit sound reasoning for either defensible supplier choice, rather than rewarding an unstated preferred answer?

Also check whether unfamiliar language, formatting or a specialist scenario adds a barrier unrelated to the skill being assessed. Ofqual’s delivery guidance identifies language and irrelevant familiarity with a task’s context as possible sources of unfair discrimination. ([gov.uk](https://www.gov.uk/guidance/ofqual-handbook/section-g-setting-and-delivering-the-assessment))

Test the tasks before deciding

  1. Work through both independently. Ask two subject-aware reviewers to draft plausible responses and note the decisions, assumptions and time each task requires.
  2. Compare possible answers. Look for a basic response and a stronger one for each version. Can the criteria distinguish their quality? Consider more than one defensible recommendation.
  3. Mark sample responses. Where your rules permit, use fictional responses to check whether reviewers interpret the criteria consistently across both versions. Resolve differences in the guidance without changing the published standard.
  4. Revise and re-review. Address material differences, then have the changed version checked again. Do not release it simply because the first comparison is complete.

If speed is not an intended skill, consider whether either version’s reading or decision-making load makes the time limit unnecessarily restrictive. An Ofqual research report on assessment time limits distinguishes assessments intended to measure speed from those where learners need sufficient time to demonstrate other skills. ([gov.uk](https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/time-limits-and-speed-of-working-in-assessments/time-limits-and-speed-of-working-in-assessments-when-and-to-what-extent-should-speed-of-working-be-part-of-what-is-assessed))

Record the decision and keep reviewing

A useful record identifies the two version numbers, reviewers, criteria checked, differences found, changes made and the person authorised to approve release. For the example above, an initial entry might say: Version B gives one supplier an advantage on every measure; revise the data to introduce a trade-off, then review again. Approval pending.

Where permitted and practical, a trial can add evidence about how tasks work in use. After delivery, review relevant feedback, response patterns and any marking concerns. Differences in results are a prompt for investigation, not proof that one task was easier: learner groups and circumstances may differ too.

Witful Journeys connects assessment steps such as checks, staff review, marking and result release. Complete and record the task-version review before offering an alternative; Journeys can then connect the subsequent human review and release steps. It does not determine automatically whether the tasks are equivalent. ([edumark.ai](https://www.edumark.ai/journeys))

Sources & further reading

A little less admin. A lot more possibility.

See how Witful connects learning, assessment and your team.

Explore Witful →